Just confirm - I assume you're using Beta 18 since you have the icon showing?
Try adding the total number of hands to the popup and see what value you get.
I wonder if the popup is showing the session stats where the table group is showing the totals. Try enabling the 'retrieve session stats for tooltips' and compare values then.
Please
enable logging, reproduce the problem by playing a few hands on a single table and submit your PokerTracker.log and PokerTrackerHUD.log files (zip/compress them first, call it logs.zip) to the
Support system , and link to this thread in the reference field of the ticket so that we can investigate.