View hands grouped by villian

[BeerNBunnies]

Was hoping someone could help me with 2 items: 1. Trying to find a report that shows my Curreny Won or Lost grouped by players. Then 2.. Report of hands where that play was the winner. I have tried using the "All Players" report but it is showing conflicting information when I then run a Hands Report with Winner = "InsertVillianName". For example... AllPlayers says I have My C Won of -$25 to Player1 over 500 hands.... When I then run HandsReport with a filter of #Winner#='Player1' it shows My C Won of -$3 over 60 hands... I cant seem to figure out what I am doing wrong. Thank you.

[BeerNBunnies]

What I believe is happening is the following... The "All Players" report shows total of hands in which that player was in... in this case for Dylanad... 316..(Matches my HUD Hand History). Now... that then shows he won 58 of them.... Now if you do a Hands Report with the filter #Winner#='Dylanad', you see that he has won 56 hands.. I think the other 2 "wins" may be split pots that are not recognized. However in this report... you can see i have lost $9.54 to him over the 56 hands in which he was the winner. So I believe the All Players Report... as well as the Player Summary Report... is showing My C Won in relation to ALL HANDS they at the table...not ALL WINNING hands... IE... If Dylanad and Gunner05 both sat at Table 1 with me... and I lost $1 to a different player... then the Player Summary would show Dylanad and Gunner05 both having "My C Won" of $-1.00 EVEN THOUGH they did not win the pot. The mere fact they were in the hand history is attributing winnings to them. If this is true... I would think this is very confusing and may not be the original intent... I would figure the intent of these reports would be to show which players have actually won or lost money to the Hero so Hero can see which players are beating him vs Hero is winning money off of.

[BeerNBunnies]

Confirmed...I changed my player to Dyland and looked at Results and low and behold .... Dylanad has a My C Won of $-24.83... Sooooo this means that the All Players Report is showing the following information: All specific players results IN YOUR CURRENCY for the hands you have tracked. It DOES NOT answer the question... "How much has each player won or lost TO ME"... very big difference... All Players Report could be useful to see who are winning vs losing players for targeting.... but does not help with Hero trying to determine which players are winning/losing VS Hero.

[Flag_Hippo]

Calculating money won/lost vs specific players is more complex where multiway pots are concerned however there is a report in PokerTracker 4 that will filter and display that data - go to the 'Results' section and select the 'Hero vs Villain' report. The top half of the report will display your winnings/losses vs each player but bear in mind the totals in the hand report below will not match the upper half as they are still the total wins/losses for you in each of those hands.

[BeerNBunnies]

Thank you sooooooooo much for this... Exactly what I was looking for and I understand why these two views would show different amounts. You are a life saver haha. It was right in front of me the whole time but I kept missing it.